Tommie's Pizza Menu
Tommie's Pizza menu gallery
Choose your favorite dish
Pizza by the Slice
Choose up to 3 topping of your choice!
New York Style cheese slice.
New York Style slice. Choose any one topping of your choice.
Desserts
Wings
2 wings sauce choices. Includes 2 dippings sauces.
1 wing sauce choice. Includes one dipping sauce.
1 wing sauce choice. Includes one dipping sauce.
Beverages
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi or Mountain Dew, Sprite, Coke, Diet Coke
Clementine peach lemon and raspberry.
Honest® Organic brings you premium organic teas, lemonade, juices, kids drinks and yerba mate tea.
Salads
Freshly chopped romaine, garden fresh veggies including grape tomatoes and cucumbers. Cheddar cheese and ranch.
Freshly chopped romaine lettuce parmesan cheese croutons and caesar dressing.
Freshly chopped romaine lettuce grilled cheese parmesan cheese croutons and caesar dressing. *Added Grilled chicken
Specialty Pizza
Mushroom, green peppers, red onions, and black olives topped with fresh spinach.
Pineapple, Canadian bacon.
Buffalo sauce, grilled chicken, & white onions.
Fresh diced tomato, grated mozzarella cheese, topped with finely cut basil.
Sausage, onions, tomatoes, sauerkraut, Mozzarella cheese topped with tomatoes.
Taco meat, taco seasoning, black olives, green peppers, topped with cheddar and Mozzarella cheese.
BBQ sauce, grilled chicken breast, & red onions.
Sausage, pepperoni, white onions and mushrooms.
Ground beef, onions, cheddar cheese, pickles, topped with lettuce and tomatoes.
Sausage, pepperoni, and bacon bits.
Fresh Mozzarella, cheddar cheese, tomatoes, onions and black olives.
Spinach, mushrooms, black olives, green peppers and red onions.
Build Your Own Classic
Add any toppings to our Classic Cheese pizza! $1.50 per topping.
Add any toppings to our Classic Cheese pizza! $1.50 per topping.
Add any toppings to our Classic Cheese pizza! $1.00 per topping.
Choose Pepperoni, Sausage, or Beef Hamburger
Sides
From a reviewer’s perspective, the menu at Tommie’s Pizza at 1556 Selby Ave offers a straightforward but fairly wide selection that covers most cravings. The Pizza by the Slice section includes simple choices like Custom Slice, Pepperoni, and Cheese / 1 Topping, making it easy for a quick grab-and-go meal. For more variety, the Specialty Pizza lineup stands out with options such as The Very Veggie, Hawaiian Pizza, Buffalo Chicken, Margherita Pizza, and The Selby, alongside a flexible Build Your Own Classic section featuring 3 Topping (16” Large), 3 Topping (12” Medium), Cheese (18” X-Large), Cheese (16” Large), and Cheese (12” Personal) for more personalized orders. Beyond pizza, the menu extends into hearty add-ons like Wings, including 6 PCS Grilled Wings, 10 Pc Grilled Wings, 20 Pcs Grilled Wings, and signature Tommie’s Grilled Wings in both 6 PCS and 20 Pcs portions. The lighter side is covered with Salads such as Garden Salad, Caesar Salad, Chicken Caesar Salad, and Grilled Cajun Chicken Caesar Salad, while snacks and sweets appear under Desserts, featuring items like Coffee Cake, Small Chips, Dirty Kettle Chips, Cheesecake, and Rocky-Road Chocolate Brownie. To round out the experience, there are Beverages including Bottled Water, Aloe Drink, 2 Liter Soda, San Pellegrino, and Pop Can, plus simple extras like Side Of Ranch and Side Of Blue Cheese. Overall, the menu feels practical and comfort-focused, centered on familiar pizza-shop staples with enough variety to satisfy both quick bites and fuller meals.